What is security of tenure under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 and how does it protect me?
The Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 gives business tenants in England and Wales the right to renew their lease at the end of the term on reasonable terms, unless the landlord can establish specific grounds for opposition under section 30 — such as intending to redevelop, requiring the premises for their own business, or persistent rent arrears. Tenants must be contracted in to the Act (not contracted out) to benefit.
What is the correct procedure for exercising a break clause in a commercial lease?
Break clauses require strict compliance with the notice requirements in the lease. Typically, you must serve a break notice in a specific form, by a specific method, to the correct recipient, and within a specified window before the break date. Courts have repeatedly held that defective break notices are ineffective even where the error is minor. Always check your lease carefully and consider serving notice by all specified methods.
What is a dilapidations schedule and how should I respond to one?
At lease end, a landlord may serve a schedule of dilapidations listing works they claim the tenant is required to carry out under the lease repairing covenants. You should obtain an independent surveyor's response promptly. The Dilapidations Protocol under the Civil Procedure Rules requires parties to follow a pre-action procedure including a Scott Schedule of disputed items before issuing proceedings.
How can I dispute a service charge in a commercial lease?
Commercial service charge disputes differ from residential ones in that statutory residential protections do not apply. You can challenge reasonableness or compliance with lease terms by negotiation, through alternative dispute resolution, or ultimately in the courts. The RICS Professional Statement on Service Charges in Commercial Property (2018) sets out best practice that landlords and managing agents should follow.
What is PACT arbitration for commercial lease renewals?
PACT (Professional Arbitration on Court Terms) is a scheme operated by RICS and the Law Society that allows parties to resolve Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 lease renewal disputes without going to court. An independent arbitrator or independent expert determines the terms of the renewed lease. PACT is faster and cheaper than court proceedings and is widely used for rent reviews and lease renewal terms.
How does RICS rent review arbitration work?
Where a lease provides for upward-only or open market rent reviews and the parties cannot agree on the new rent, a landlord or tenant can refer the matter to a RICS-appointed arbitrator or independent expert. The arbitrator considers comparables and market evidence and determines the revised rent. The process is binding and the arbitrator's fee is usually borne equally.
What is forfeiture and how can a commercial tenant seek relief?
Forfeiture allows a landlord to terminate a commercial lease for breach of covenant, most commonly non-payment of rent. A landlord may peaceably re-enter the premises (for non-rent breaches, a section 146 notice must first be served). A tenant threatened with or subject to forfeiture can apply to court for relief under section 146 of the Law of Property Act 1925 or under the court's equitable jurisdiction.
Are there any legacy disputes under the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Act 2022?
The Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Act 2022 created an arbitration scheme for protected rent debts accrued during mandatory business closures between March 2020 and July 2021. The arbitration window closed in September 2022, but some legacy disputes around enforcement of pre-pandemic arrears and whether debts qualify as protected continue to arise and may still be contested.
Does any part of the commercial lease dispute process require a solicitor?
Negotiating directly with your landlord, referring a dispute to PACT or RICS arbitration, and applying for forfeiture relief can all be done without a solicitor. Court proceedings for lease renewal or dilapidations claims above small claims limits benefit greatly from specialist legal input given the complexity of property law and the costs at stake.
How does uplaw.ai help with commercial lease disputes in England?
Tell us about your lease, what the dispute is about, and what stage you are at. We help you understand your rights under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, draft a response to a dilapidations schedule, and identify whether PACT or RICS arbitration is the right route for your situation.
Free to start
Commercial lease dispute? Tell uplaw.ai what happened.
No account required. uplaw.ai identifies your rights under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 and the right dispute route for your situation.